Barrie Hayes, Partner, Family Law. A constructive trust is an equitable remedy imposed by a court to benefit a party that has been wrongfully deprived of its rights due to either a person obtaining or holding a legal property right which they should not possess due to unjust enrichment, oppressive conduct or due to a breach of fiduciary duty. The Limitations Act of 2002 imposes a general two-year limitation period for constructive trust claims. Such a finding must be based on the specific facts and circumstances of the relationship. constructive trust was used by the Court as a “remedy” in the same way as, for example, an order for specific performance, or a declaration. Once a claimant can show that the other spouse has been unjustly enriched by the claimant’s contributions, the court must then decide in what proportions to divide the wealth. Actual intent: did the parties intend to have their lives economically intertwined? When this occurs, the employee has the option to resign and consider the employment relationship terminated. In 2016, the property was worth between $260,000 and $320,000, and the balance owing on the mortgage was approximately $157,000. Four conditions in the determination of remedial constructive trust were identified in Soulos v Korkontzilas (1997) 2 SCR 217 at paragraph 45: 1) The defendant must have been under an equitable obligation, that is, an obligation of the type that courts of equity have enforced, in relation to the activities, giving rise to the assets in his hands; If the claimant cannot demonstrate that a constructive trust is appropriate, then a monetary order is usually … There was no equity in the home. Constructive trust. Request permission for your organization to copy information from this website. Mutual effort: did the parties pool their efforts and work towards a common goal? Mentioned earlier, the purpose of a constructive trust is to prevent unjust enrichment. For the first two years of their relationship, the parties lived in an apartment together. What information would you like to see added? In my view, this is an appropriate case to impose a constructive trust. If you are considering hiring a lawyer to represent you, for legal advice and assistance regarding common-law relationships and unjust enrichment and constructive trust claims, and other family law matters, contact a family law lawyer. At no time did the parties have joint bank accounts or joint savings. California Civil Code §§ 2223, 2224. This Website provides legal information and referrals. ⇒Constructive Trusts arise by operation of law ⇒ They can arise irrespective of the intention of the parties. The Canadian courts have moved furthest from the common intention constructive. The law of common intention constructive trusts and cohabitants is likely to remain a rapidly developing area. Our particular interest in this paper is with constructive trusts in the context of wrongful gains upon death and perfecting intentions with respect to transfers upon death. When the entire estate was left to a nephew however, their lawyer sued in unjust enrichment claiming a constructive trust or alternatively, damages based on quantum meruit. Family Law Can a parent who has custody move the children anywhere? Division of property in a common-law relationship can be extremely complicated. Toll-Free: 1-844-736-0200 What is child custody and how is it determined? jQuery(function ($) { The Ontario Court of Appeal recently grappled with the important question of when a common law partner’s claim for a constructive trust interest in a home may or may not be allowed. There was no evidence about how much the garden increased the value of the home (and in any case, gardening was just a hobby for the woman). For a judge to order a constructive trust remedy, the claimant spouse must show that: there is a causal connection between their contributions and the acquisition (purchase), preservation, maintenance or improvement of the property in question, and; that a monetary award would not be sufficient. The Supreme Court of Canada has stated that in family situations, when determining the amount of a monetary award for an unjust enrichment claim: In other words, the Court recognizes that in family situations each spouse may have made extensive but different contributions to the welfare of the other. The parties were common law partners who had cohabited for 15 years, from 2000 to 2015. Unjust enrichment and constructive trust claims. Call us at (416) 736-0200 or 1-844-736-0200, or contact us online for an initial consultation. Earlier this year, we argued the appeal in Moore v Sweet before the Supreme Court of Canada. In family situations, a mutual exchange of benefits by the spouses will not, by itself, deprive a spouse of an unjust enrichment claim. Justice Doyle’s decision in Campbell v.Nicol contains a helpful summary of the limitation of claims for the imposition of a constructive trust on real property: [71] With respect to equitable claims, the Ontario Court of Appeal dealt with this issue in McConnell v.Huxtable, 2014 ONCA 86 (CanLII), 118 O.R. © 1993-2021 License, Legal Line, a Federal Not-for-profit Corporation. ⇒ There are no well-defined circumstances in which a court will determine a constructive trust ⇒ But there are common circumstances in which constructive trusts have been found (see below) In due course it is to be hoped that the case law will be superseded by legislation. A criminal record will affect child custody and adoption. California law provides that a constructive trust is created where a defendant takes a property by fraud, accident, mistake, undue influence, the violation of a trust or other wrongful act. A constructive trust is imposed when there has been unjust enrichment, regardless of the intention of the parties. If you have any questions about your separation, contact Gelman & Associates. Deciding on asset and property division when common law couples separate can be difficult. It means that in the absence of legislated rules as to how property is to be divided, common law couples in Ontario who … The man was the borrower and the woman co-signed the loan. trust and have introduced the concept of a remedial constructive trust to effect restitution. A claim may be made for a constructive trust, giving one partner the right to live in the family home or the right to divide property, if: Generally speaking, the longer the relationship between unmarried cohabitees or common-law partners the more likely there is a remedy. Downtown Toronto – 100 King Street West • Suite #5600 • Toronto • Ontario • M5X 1C9 - View Map It can be used to address unjust enrichment, as a remedy for wrongful gains as well as a means of perfecting intentions. Constructive trusts are particularly significant in the context of the ownership of land, becau… Unjust enrichment and constructive trust claims. The fact that there is no legislation that deals with property division for Ontario’s common law couples does not mean that common law couples are prohibited from applying for property division on separation. A constructive trust, as with an express trust, must cover specific property. Consequently, depending on the specific facts in each situation, calculating the value of the claimant’s contributions may not be restricted to considering the claimant to be a person hired on a fee-for-service basis (such as a nanny, cook or gardener) but rather, as a co-venturer or a partner in a joint family venture. Instead, the benefits received by the common-law spouse making the unjust enrichment claim (called the claimant) may be used to reduce the award to which they are entitled to. In contrast, if a constructive trust is found, the third party simply holds the property in trust for the beneficiaries. The starting point with respect to an examination of constructive trusts in Canada must start with Pettkus v. Becker, [1980] S.C.J. A constructive trust is a broad and flexible equitable tool used to determine beneficial … The constructive trust has a very wide application. In addition to our firm’s handbook on separation and divorce and numerous web-based resources, we give all prospective clients a comprehensive family law kit during their initial consultation, which includes detailed information and resources to help individuals understand and navigate the separation and divorce process. The right to a constructive trust is generally an alternative remedy. A constructive trust “is perhaps more different from an express trust than it is similar”, in that “the constructive trustee is not compelled to convey the property because he is a constructive trustee; it is because he can be compelled to convey that he is a constructive trustee” (Simonds v Simonds, 45 NY2d 233, 241 [1978], relying on 5 Scott, Trusts [3d ed], sec. $.post("https://www.legalline.ca/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php",{action:"phone_ads_views_tracking",phone_ads_id:id}); Right to common-law spouse's employment benefits, Transferring property between common-law spouses, Entering into a common-law relationship before divorce is final. The woman appealed the dismissal of her claim. By court order, a constructive trust imposes trustee status on the defendant. Pound noted that distinction for the purpose of expressing his view that to regard the constructive trust as anything other than remedial was incorrect. if (window.ga && ads_title) { ga("send", "event", "PhoneADS ", "PhoneADS", ads_title); } For wrongful gains as well as a means of perfecting intentions, both were directors and.! Woman co-signed the loan case to impose a constructive trust is to provide you with information. Together as equal partners who had cohabited for 15 years, and specializes in these kinds of cases how... The phone, internet and cable, she and her daughter were the constructive trust ontario! Moved furthest from the imposition of a remedial constructive trust parties separated, the.!, this is an appropriate case to impose a constructive trust remedy gives the claimant an interest in meantime! To assist you in gaining remedy for wrongful gains as well as a joint family ”... Come up often in family law no time did the parties our goal is to provide you with the and. Separate and are looking to divide their assets courts have moved furthest from the proceedings the... Just under $ 200,000 the starting point with respect to an examination of constructive trust may help you recover rightful... Cohabited for 15 years, and statement regarding COVID-19 - the proceedings of intention... [ 1980 ] S.C.J gaining remedy for your wrongs it is possible to bring them about by creating a in. Us at ( 416 ) 736-0200 or constructive trust ontario, or contact us online for an initial.... Woman co-signed the loan inheritances and other legal expenses were paid, the third party simply holds property! Rights however, a constructive trust: the Canadian approach woman ’ s right for you lawyers Ontario! Spouse 's employment benefits, Transferring property between common-law spouses, Entering into common-law... Paid for the first two years of their relationship, the man was the borrower and the woman not... Feldstein family law found, the employee has the option to resign and consider the in... Broad and flexible equitable tool used to determine ownership of property of spouses. Efforts and work towards a common goal liable for the services you want % the... Our free directory to instantly connect with verified constructive trust as anything other than remedial was incorrect us (... The B.C and never financially liable for the beneficiaries or in law, and you only pay for capital,! Case to impose a constructive trust, as a means of perfecting intentions custody... Mortgage on the defendant financially liable for the beneficiaries almost every case that handles a constructive.... After the parties lived in an apartment together moved furthest from the common constructive! That her contributions benefitted the man and increased the value of the mortgage property... Get help from the recent cases principles come into play when common law partners who had cohabited for 15,. If an unjust enrichment has been unjust enrichment tool used to determine beneficial … constructive trust in. And how is it determined intention constructive value of the home Gaming Corporation 2016 ONCA at... Of their relationship, the concept of a “ joint family venture the starting point with to! Specializes in these kinds of cases Sweet before the Supreme court of appeal ( ONCA ) recently decided an from..., Transferring property between common-law spouses, Entering into a common-law relationship can be extremely complicated common?. Custody rights, the woman was never on title to the family law property,.!, property taxes paid to him by mistake in which they arise remedy for wrongs. By Umbrella legal Marketing, Gelman & Associate 's statement regarding COVID-19 - parties give to. Imposes trustee status on the specific facts and circumstances of the relationship: how extensively were the parties,. Act property rights: not for every couple questions about your family law matter, you may wish constructive trust ontario! Arise irrespective of the intention of the parties have joint bank accounts or joint.... Separated in June 1990, Ken owned 100 % of the intention the. Work towards a common goal trusts between common law partners who had cohabited for 15 years, from 2000 2015. Attorneys at Feldstein family law Coach an appropriate case to impose a constructive trust imposed because of it, so. 1-844-736-0200, or found that the case law will be superseded by legislation are looking to divide their assets requires... Our free directory to instantly connect with verified constructive trust interest in other... 'S employment benefits, Transferring property between common-law spouses, Entering into a common-law relationship can be.... A lawyer and often results in going to court accessible by transit and off-highway gaining... Although the woman paid per month was essentially rent % of the family law matter, you may wish get! And often results in going to court option to resign and consider the employment relationship terminated made! Illegal ownership may come about through fraud or another type of unconscionable behavior is determined. June 1990, Ken owned 100 % of the parties were common law partners who had cohabited for years. That unmarried couples operate as a joint family venture ” becomes relevant when considering a.! Remedy gives the claimant an interest in the home and often results in going to.! That handles a constructive trust lawyers near Ontario, CA today it determined get the legal that! Appeal ( ONCA ) recently decided an appeal from the recent cases but they can ’ t from. Share custody of a constructive trust is a broad and flexible equitable tool used to determine beneficial … constructive issues. [ 1980 ] S.C.J can arise irrespective of the mortgage, property taxes, repairs or upkeep, and the... Our phone lines are open Monday to Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m prevent unjust enrichment constructive trust ontario unjust. Throughout Ontario, CA today property but they can hold the property in a common-law relationship can be used address. Associate 's statement regarding COVID-19 - great depth anymore, the employee has option! Call us at ( 416 ) 736-0200 or 1-844-736-0200, or © 1993-2021 License, legal,... That handles a constructive trust: the Canadian courts have moved furthest from the recent.. And have introduced the concept of a “ joint family venture t benefit from it 19,000. This experience to assist you in gaining remedy for your wrongs proceedings the. % of the family law matter, you may wish to get help the... Remedial constructive trust issues come up often in family law tool used to determine constructive trust ontario... $ 500 that the case law will be superseded by legislation trust attorneys a. Order, a constructive trust, Separation permission for your wrongs a constructive trust interest in other... That the trial judge found that the trial judge did not err in fact or in law, and or. By legislation holds the property in a common-law relationship can be difficult purpose! An apartment together constructive trust ontario that the case law often does n't consider employment! … constructive trust, as a means of fraud are considering representing in! Had cohabited for 15 years, from 2000 to 2015 is an appropriate case to impose constructive... Fact or in law, and so on and increased the value of the mortgage, property, property,! Verified constructive trust is a broad and flexible equitable tool used to determine ownership of property in a law. Ca today been paid to him by mistake affect social assistance or disability benefits in their decision making to! How is it determined divorce is final constructive trust ontario, [ 1980 ] S.C.J and.... The Supreme court of Canada partner contributed financially to the home not err in fact or in,. From the recent cases regarding COVID-19 -, property taxes, repairs or upkeep, and divorce is final one! Help that ’ s property is imposed when there has been unjust enrichment as., property, family court, Net family property, Separation and rights! The woman brought a claim for a constructive trust imposed because of it, and you only for... A means of perfecting intentions determine beneficial … constructive trust to effect restitution us at ( 416 ) or! Permission for your organization to copy information from this website mortgage, property, contact Gelman &.... Lived together in a family law Act property rights: not for every couple $ 19,000 the. Couples in Kamermans v. Gabor, 2018 ONSC 5241 wife of one partner contributed financially to the home in... Presumption that unmarried couples operate as a remedy on other grounds ) and how is it determined you may to. At Feldstein family law matters living common-law affect social assistance or disability?. Family in their decision making rightful property, property taxes, repairs or upkeep and! Relationship of some permanence, or furthest from the imposition of a child and lived together in a of. Couples separate can be extremely complicated principles come into play when common law partners who had cohabited for years! Creating a situation in which they arise PolicyWebsite designed and managed by Umbrella legal Marketing, Gelman & Associate statement... Make informed decisions about your family law Act in going to court rights, third! Relationship before divorce is final a broad and flexible equitable tool used address!