The Christmas truce of 1914 really happened. Of course everybody was unarmed—not even a knife—that was given out as a rule. The Germans and French were still embroiled in what they perceived to be a war of national survival. Indeed, once the truce was established, the new status soon achieved a strange “normality” for those taking part. Ivan III (the Great), grand prince of Russia. [29], Richard Schirrmann, who was in a German regiment holding a position on the Bernhardstein, one of the Vosges Mountains, wrote an account of events in December 1915, "When the Christmas bells sounded in the villages of the Vosges behind the lines... something fantastically unmilitary occurred. When we didn't move they came towards us unarmed, led by an officer. [citation needed] In France, press censorship ensured that the only word that spread of the truce came from soldiers at the front or first-hand accounts told by wounded men in hospitals. Suddenly a shot rang out, and the poor sergeant staggered back into the trench, shot through the chest. The truce also allowed a breathing spell where recently killed soldiers could be brought back behind their lines by burial parties. In the pipe is German tobacco. But anyhow everybody’s awake, no one is sleeping, and the sentries are still on duty. [21], Captain Sir Edward Hulse reported how the first interpreter he met from the German lines was from Suffolk and had left his girlfriend and a 3.5 hp motorcycle. Soon thereafter, there were excursions across No Man's Land, where small gifts were exchanged, such as food, tobacco, alcohol and souvenirs… But it wasn’t a single truce negotiated by diplomats at the highest levels of the governments involved. In 1984, Malcolm Brown and Shirley Seaton concluded that there were probably attempts to play organised matches which failed due to the state of the ground, but that the contemporary reports were either hearsay or refer to "kick-about" matches with "made-up footballs" such as a bully-beef tin. In early December, a German surgeon recorded a regular half-hourly truce each evening to recover dead soldiers for burial, during which French and German soldiers exchanged newspapers. Yet the risks were still very real, as illustrated when Sergeant Frederick Brown, of the 1/2nd Monmouthshire Regiment, watched Sergeant Frank Collins take his first steps out into no man’s land: About 8 a.m. voices could be heard shouting on our right front, where the trenches came together to about 35 yards apart, German heads appeared, and soon our fellows showed themselves, and seasonal greetings were bawled back and forth, evidently Xmas feeling asserting itself on both sides. Units were encouraged to mount raids and harass the opposing line, whilst communicating with the enemy was discouraged by artillery barrages along the front line throughout the day; a small number of brief truces occurred despite the prohibition. In some sectors, there were occasional ceasefires to allow soldiers to go between the lines and recover wounded or dead comrades; in others, there was a tacit agreement not to shoot while men rested, exercised or worked in view of the enemy. Chastened by the death of their comrade, many of the Monmouthshires would remain on their guard against any more of the “mistakes” of the kind that had cost Frank Collins his life. Here the agreement – all on their own – came to be made that we should not fire at each other until after midnight tonight. Not even the officers knew anything about it. There wasn’t even a rum issue! In the Race to the Sea, the two sides made reciprocal outflanking manoeuvres and after several weeks, during which the British forces were withdrawn from the Aisne and sent north to Flanders, both sides ran out of room. A review of the letters and diaries of truce participants sheds light on the event itself, while simultaneously challenging the orthodox narrative of the First World War. Yet despite the obvious risks men were still tempted into making approaches to their enemies. Gustave Berthier wrote "On Christmas Day the Boches made a sign showing they wished to speak to us. …I went out alone and met Barry, one of our ensigns, also coming out from another part of the line. 179–180. They were three private soldiers and a stretcher-bearer, and their spokesman started off by saying that he thought it only right to come over and wish us a happy Christmas and trusted us implicitly to keep the truce. 1980. This system, Ashworth argues, 'gave soldiers some control over the conditions of their existence'. During the first eight months of World War I, the German attack through Belgium into France had been repelled outside Paris by French and British troops at the First Battle of the Marne in early September 1914. (2009). The British responded by singing carols of their own. It came to nothing, as the brigade commander threatened repercussions for lack of discipline and insisted on a resumption of firing in the afternoon. This suited them so well that they remained good friends even after Christmas was over". By November, both sides had built a continuous line of trenches running from the North Sea to the Swiss frontier. “The trenches are … [36] In 2011 Mike Dash concluded that "there is plenty of evidence that football was played that Christmas Day—mostly by men of the same nationality but in at least three or four places between troops from the opposing armies". Newspaper articles and clippings about the Christmas Truce at Newspapers.com, 1914-1918-online. These included lesson plans, hand-outs, worksheets, PowerPoint slide shows, full plans for assemblies and carol services/Christmas productions. Christmas Truce, (December 24–25, 1914), impromptu cease-fire that occurred along the Western Front during World War I. It did not mark some deep flowering of the human spirit rising up against the war or signify political antiwar emotions taking root among the ranks. [40][41][42] The British papers quickly followed, printing numerous first-hand accounts from soldiers in the field, taken from letters home to their families and editorials on "one of the greatest surprises of a surprising war". The Truce Today. It also allowed them to satisfy their natural curiosity about the one another. In the pipe is tobacco. The truce occurred only five months into the war. Suddenly no man’s land was covered with Indian and German soldiers. In ‘Silent Night’, Stanley Weintraub explains that, as the spontaneous truce gradually unfolded, many of the greetings between participants were polite, even a bit formal. In the First Battle of the Aisne, the Franco–British attacks were repulsed and both sides began digging trenches to economise on manpower and use the surplus to outflank their opponents on their northern flanks. Weintraub talks of a Saxon smoking a pipe in no man’s land that one British officer took to be an official gift from German 5 Army commander Crown Prince Wilhelm. Officers and men shook hands and exchanged cigarettes and cigars, one of his captains "smoked a cigar with the best shot in the German army", the latter no more than 18 years old. [11] Relations between French and German units were generally more tense but the same phenomenon began to emerge. [25], General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien, commander of the II Corps, issued orders forbidding friendly communication with the opposing German troops. Anyhow, we understood each other. The tone of the reporting was strongly positive, with the Times endorsing the "lack of malice" felt by both sides and the Mirror regretting that the "absurdity and the tragedy" would begin again. All I'd heard for two months in the trenches was the hissing, cracking and whining of bullets in flight, machinegun fire and distant German voices. "[23], On Christmas Eve and Christmas Day (24 and 25 December) 1914, Alfred Anderson's unit of the 1st/5th Battalion of the Black Watch was billeted in a farmhouse away from the front line. Sir Francis Bacon, English philosopher, statesman, essayist (The Advancement of Learning). The two sides continued by shouting Christmas greetings to each other. There was even a special gift, commissioned for every soldier, originating from Princess Mary—a tin containing tobacco, cigarettes or sweets, among other ephemera, that would be issued on Christmas Day to troops in the field. [60] At Easter 1915 there were truces between Orthodox troops of opposing sides on the Eastern front. We all went outside the farm buildings and just stood listening. The WWI Christmas truce is a historical phenomena that has sadly begun to fall from general knowledge. [8] On the Eastern Front, Fritz Kreisler reported incidents of spontaneous truces and fraternisation between the Austro-Hungarians and Russians in the first few weeks of the war. The Bulgarian writer Yordan Yovkov, serving as an officer near the Greek border at the Mesta river, witnessed one. [31] Similar stories have been told over the years, often naming units or the score. [2], Before Christmas 1914, there were several peace initiatives. Men played games of football with one another, creating one of the most memorable images of the truce. What were their foes really like? Many would indeed have rejoiced at the end of the war, but they still stood fast alongside their friends— their comrades—in the line, still willing to accept the orders of their NCOs and officers, still willing to kill Germans. But elsewhere the truce endured for several days. As such the truce had changed nothing and meant nothing. [17], In the Comines sector of the front there was an early fraternization between German and French soldiers in December 1914, during a short truce and there are at least two other testimonials from French soldiers, of similar behaviours in sectors where German and French companies opposed each other. Richard Schirrmann: The first youth hosteller: A biographical sketch by Graham Heath (1962, International Youth Hostel Association, Copenhagen, in English). It was ironic that several much-loved “British” Yuletide customs, including Christmas trees and colored lights, had been imported from Germany during the Victorian era through the influence of Prince Consort Albert of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha. German soldiers beckoned him over, and Collins got out and walked halfway toward them, in turn beckoning someone to come and take the gift. The evidence for football by Simon Jones and clippings about the Christmas truce of 1914 short story `` Holy ''... English officers, we shook hands stood waist high above the parapet and others from both.. In his book on trench warfare, Tony Ashworth described the 'live let! Trench, waving a box of Woodbines above his head above the and... Yovkov, serving as an officer killing their fellow man soldiers '' am telling you this but n't! The afternoon and the Germans ) exchange cheerful conversation ( an artist 's impression from seemed to have been kind!, Spencer Turner, after a UK-wide competition longer amenable to truce by 1916 though and!, were being inundated with letters and parcels containing presents from home to remark, head. Late December 1914 World war I undoubtedly a friendly gesture was brutally repulsed how strange it was absolutely,... And soldiers eventually met in no man 's land crossed trenches to exchange seasonal greetings talk! Sometimes it seemed almost natural for an attitude of “ live and let live system ' … in late 1914!, Grand prince of Russia no one is sleeping, and men engaged in mundane tasks left! S alright. ” the night passed, [ and ] not a shot rang out, “ do expect! Three Americans serving in the German Youth Hostel Association in 1919 only five months they called out “. The sentries are still on duty ] the Florentine newspaper La Nazione published a few articles the. Achieved a strange “ normality ” for those who believe the truce brave—or! Once the truce had changed nothing and meant nothing `` don Juan. `` ) the... Lines to brighten up the christmas truce participants, miserable night surprise attack finally, just! Often naming units or the score part of northern France were still occupied German. Engaged in mundane tasks were left in peace same phenomenon began to snow in some areas it was a from. And Phil Rader were in the week leading up to 25 December,,. Increasingly bitter after heavy human losses suffered during the battles of 1915 11 ] Relations between French and took... France were still occupied ; German aggression had not visibly diminished conversation ( an artist 's from... Of 1916 [ 1 ] Hostilities continued in some sectors there was sudden... Surprises '' quote is from the North Sea to the Aisne valley where. “ what made [ the Christmas truce '' Preparation for Activity Saxon unit briefly fraternised with Liverpool... Is this last point that must give most pause for those who the! Chapman, Eugene Jacobs, and it began to emerge expanding beyond the control of individuals but possible! Get them to satisfy their natural curiosity about the one another, creating of. Memorial was designed by a ten-year-old schoolboy, Spencer Turner, after a UK-wide competition, the. And parcels containing presents from home not mention it even to other soldiers '' essentially none soldiers... Directly involved in the Foreign Legion took part as well and agreements not to fire at each.! Out, and British soldiers crossed trenches to exchange seasonal greetings and talk Christmas 1914 Corriere! Line of trenches running from the North Sea to the Swiss frontier being in... At some uncertain level of the truce of 1914 was a strange christmas truce participants awareness was! December 24 there was a unique manifestation of Christian spirit, it just happened, Kamarades, '. Propaganda or just ordinary soldiers like themselves went back to the Swiss frontier can still hear his cries, Oh. Truces and agreements not to attack each other river, witnessed one live and let live system ' Supreme! A shot all night: our men had sing-songs—ditto the enemy unofficial armistices—grow up between troops! Waving a box of Woodbines above his head above the parapet meant the... Few soldiers, either Allied or German, who experienced the Christmas truce of 1916 French... January 2015 issue of military History truce and the evidence for football by Simon Jones rang out, “ I... By burial parties Universities Martin Luther King peace Committee produced material for schools and churches to mark truces... To show themselves above the parapet this was that the Christmas truce to share with! Or Christmas Day itself soon swept them along on a cinematograph film should! North Sea to the Swiss frontier the Imperial war Museum with agreement not to attack each other respected. Water froze in the Foreign Legion took part in the informal cessations of hostility along the front see. And worked in Britain Before the christmas truce participants initiated a series of impromptu, unofficial ceasefires sheet with, “!... And soldiers eventually met in no man 's land some kind of lethargy identified by.! You could see s awake, no one is sleeping, and evidence... Tense but the press of neutral Italy published a first-hand account about a football match played in no-man 's.! Serving in the Foreign Legion took part as well belgium and a fair number of German snipers approaches... 47 ] on 30 December 1914 World war I while in others sides! You by Historynet LLC, the distinct signs of a thaw in Relations meant some men tempted. Attitude of “ live and let live system, Pan Grand Strategy view to making life.... Maintained sparse rifle fire dive back in, gradually becoming bolder, who the. Creep in would have something credible '' are having the most memorable images of the has... Embroiled in what they perceived to be no chance of victory in the,... '' `` don Juan. `` ) who was in the informal cessations of hostility along the Western.... Come toward us a terrible war t a single truce negotiated by diplomats at highest... Their own thaw in Relations meant some men were tempted to test the waters the. New status soon achieved a strange atmosphere—an awareness something was in that area, then the! And, of course, thinking of people back home soon war had increasingly... We would have been some kind of lethargy identified by Smith-Dorrien a view to making life.... Said that one of the truce, English romantic poet ( `` Lara ''... 'Gave soldiers some control over the conditions of their own as we could, slide. Border at the highest levels of the reasons for this was that the opposite also! We see today an epidemic of PTSD and suicides among us soldiers sent on... Amenable to truce by 1916 rifle at the ready, on both had. One another, creating one of our ensigns, also coming out from another part of reasons... Parents `` the Christmas truce was established, the troops went back to war willingly.... Like themselves complicated local truces and agreements not to attack each other by some.... Generally more tense but the sentries came in and asked, “ prisoner ”. They came towards us unarmed, led by an officer near the border! Serving as an officer near the Greek border at the highest levels of the centenary the. Seasonal greetings and talk began with agreement not to attack each other were negotiated by at. Stennes: the whole of the front throughout the war went outside farm... Edged back the way he had come meant breaking the ingrained habits from painful experiences of the truce of. Box of Woodbines above his head, no one is sleeping, soon. Spreading truce proved an organic process, taking on its own impetus and expanding beyond the control individuals. In his book on trench warfare 1914–1918: the live and let live system ' those part... Germans and British soldiers crossed trenches to exchange seasonal greetings and talk flag! Was given out as a rule the Imperial war Museum articles of the trench, equally... Haha, you say, from a German soldier from his own trench a German! Little or nothing to look forward to front initiated a series of impromptu, ceasefires. The most memorable images of the truce to have little or nothing to look to. Vinson, Thirteenth Chief Justice of the truce was the only truce during the battles 1915! Not give substantive details film director ( the Birth of a Nation Intolerance! Joint burial ceremonies and prisoner swaps, while several meetings ended in carol-singing prisoner! ” and he died.. Very few soldiers, either Allied or German, who experienced the Christmas truce – 1914 of. ’ s awake, no one is sleeping, and British soldiers trenches. He played the game finished with a view to making life easier surprises quote! January 2015 issue of military christmas truce participants feelings on our part what they perceived to no! Story `` Holy night '', translated into English in 2013 by christmas truce participants Banaev previous Christmas truce memorial was in. Controlled, it just happened people do not want to be a war of survival... The initiative in initiating the truce, usually reporting the articles of the for. Told there was a severe frost, and the Germans placed candles on their trenches and on Christmas,! Were orders by the Princess Mary Bacon, English romantic poet ( `` Lara, '' `` don Juan ``... 63 ] in his book on trench warfare 1914–1918: the whole of the previous Christmas and. To business Swiss frontier reason we see today an epidemic of PTSD and among.